Paris- Story of Immigrants, Beggars and Yellow Vests

When my flight was about to touch the runway of Charles-De-Gaulle airport, I could see the thick clouds from the small window of the plane. Within moments rainwater lashed on the windowpane with a loud crackling sound. I understood that Paris was welcoming me with rain and thunderstorm. This was not exactly what I would have preferred. However, what else could I have expected in November end?

Charles de Gaulle was confusing enough to make me run from one direction to the other in search of the exit. In the flight, there was another Indian guy, I found him equally fumbling, looking for the exit. I went near him and asked, “are you looking for the exit?” He nodded excitedly, the usual excitement that we feel when we meet another confused desi in a foreign land. He said he was doing Ph.D. from IIT Delhi and had come to Paris for a seminar. The ‘introductory’ conversation went on while we searched the exit.

As the saying in Hindi goes “ek se bhale do” and together we found the exit. We took the airport shuttle and went to Terminal 1 from where we wanted to take the airport train to the Gare Du Nord station in Paris city. The airport internal shuttle is free but for the RER train, we had to buy tickets.

There was a huge queue in front of the ticket vending machine. We stood patiently and then when our turn came we fumbled. Our forex cards were not working and we had no coins. Helplessly we looked around and an African-French man came to our rescue. He patiently explained us the process and even stood there like a diligent teacher till we got the tickets. “Merci Beaucoup” I said before leaving.

The view of rainy Paris suburbs from the train was mesmerizing for our third world eyes.  We were enjoying every bit of the suburbs and French countryside. The empty stations, the small row houses, the leafless branches, the almost empty roads were just magnifying our French infatuation. However, the infatuation didn’t last long as soon factory chimneys and malls started obstructing views. The view inside the train was also like a distant cousin of our very own Virar local with beggars and homeless people asking for money exactly the way they do in India. Well, not exactly the same because here beggars are literate and they distribute leaflets to beg. In India, beggars appeal to your pity but in Paris, they appeal to your guilt.

When foreigners come to India they make it a point to click the photos of poor people, our dirt, our slums, our beggars and our potholes. Maybe this is the time we Indians also start doing the same. We should also start clicking their potholes, homeless people, the beggars, the substance addicts and other street urchins that populate the streets of western countries. Strangely when I visited a small country Bhutan I did not find a single homeless person or a beggar. Yet all of us are busy fantasizing about the West. This time I even saw huge rodents running on the streets of Paris. The Paris metro was heavy with the smell of urine and the streets of Paris were full of dog poop.

The place where I stayed near the Gare Du Nord train station resembled a set for a mafia movie. The shops were full of Chinese goods. The streets were full of immigrants (probably most of them illegal) from Africa and Arab countries. The Estacao Barbes- Rochechouart metro station near my accommodation was one of the filthiest stations that I have ever seen.  Each time I went out the guy at the reception warned me of pickpockets. There was a Burger King outlet nearby and the girl at the counter also warned me of pickpockets and muggers. The place used to get really scary at night.

The “yellow vest” movement was brewing while I was in Paris and the whole city had an alarmingly anxious and tensed ambiance. Police and barricades were everywhere. The Christmas season was overlapped with the tensed atmosphere.  Paris is a dream destination for many including myself but the Paris I saw this time was very different from the usual city of lights, this time it looked dark and sinister. The cloud that welcomed me to Paris now seemed like an allegory.


28 thoughts on “Paris- Story of Immigrants, Beggars and Yellow Vests

  1. Shalzmojo says:

    So nothing much has changed since I first visited Paris in 2008 😉

    I too was speechless with the state of metro stations, confusion at the airport and the general ambience in the city as a whole. I was there for 8 days and explored most of it to my heart’s content but the beggars and the feeling on being unsafe on the streets at night were my constant companion too.

    You are so right about our fascination with the West- I had a very rosy picture of Paris and the tourist places I visited were some of the most amazing ones in terms of infrastructure and architecture.

    But yes no one talks about this side of Paris. I was warmed by a dozen people to be careful of pickpockets and bag snatchers; 3 of my relatives, one of my friends and one work colleague had shared their Europe horrors about this from their trips with me.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Balaka says:

      Few years back I met few French people in Mumbai. They had come here and were busy clicking picture of Dharavi, as if the only identity of Mumbai is Dharavi. They were clicking the sadhus on the streets. Now I so desperately feel like giving it back to them. Compared to Paris we have lesser homeless people and our beggars are not aggressive as the French ones. In Mumbai I never feel scared at night but in Paris I felt scared.


  2. mjothi says:

    Welcome to reality!!!
    I too had a rosy picture of WEST until I landed in US in early 2000. Its not always as rosy as it is in western media, same way India is not as bad as it is shown in our indian media!!!
    Living in Europe, I can see a clear change in here. Now you know why NRIs pick an interest of India once out of India 🙂


  3. neelstoria says:

    Quite interesting to read about the not-so-good things about Paris. I had a similar experience when I went to New York. Not to this extent though but I found the streets, lanes, and metro to be dirtier than I had expected.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. the bespectacled mother says:

    This was the honest travel tale I have ever read. When it comes to Paris, all I have read how beautiful, lovely, wonderful place is it, all the good adjectives rolled out together. But it is never the whole truth. Big cities around the world are the same when it comes to the problems and their becoming dangerous at night. In my experience, people speak of London as in it is the best place in the world, but trust me I have only been there as a tourist 3 times in the last 5 years and each time when I get back home to my small city, I get this feeling I am back from the dread.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Becoming Spanish says:

    Indeed interesting that you share your personal experience in Paris while “yellow vest” movement is taking place. I, too, am writing stories from immigrants’ perspectives, and I appreciate to see the similarities that unite these stories all while keeping each of them unique.

    Liked by 1 person

Did you like my post? Please let me know

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.